How the Presence of Talent in Cities Could be Worth $124 Billion How the Presence of Talent in Cities Could be Worth $124 Billion
How the Presence of Talent in Cities Could be Worth $124 Billion
Urban policy is generally understood to include such things as housing, neighborhood revitalization, and poverty alleviation. While all of these are important to the success of cities, even in combination they don't come close to equaling the importance of talent to the success of cities.
Talent-defined as the percentage of college graduates in a city's population-explains almost 60 percent of a city's success as measured by per capita income. To wit: If urban policy does not include the development, attraction, and retention of talent, it doesn't have a prayer of making a real difference for cities. But this truth isn't easily absorbed by urban leaders.
But if we could increase college attainment by just 1 percent in each of the top 51 metro areas-areas with 1 million or more residents-the nation will realize an additional $124 billion in personal income. We call that the "Talent Dividend."
Break that number down locally and it becomes even more impressive. In Indianapolis, for instance, a 1 percentage point increase in college attainment would result in a $1.3 billion annual increase in personal income. According to the city's leaders, that is roughly equal to the local payroll of the city's largest employer, Eli Lilly.
If local leaders believed they could recruit a business that equaled the size of their city's largest employer, what would they do? They would fire up the corporate jets, put together an aggressive package of tax incentives, stage lavish dinners, put the governor on call, and put the mayor out in front of the effort. That is essentially what is at stake with a relatively small increase in college attainment among a city's population.
There are three ways to increase talent:
You can attract talent.
You can develop talent.
You can retain talent.
For many cities, attracting talent seems like a cheap shortcut to solving the problem. It doesn't require the expensive, hard slog that developing talent requires. But if talent only moves from one place to another, that means no net gain of talent to the nation. Besides, it's not a winning proposition for most cities. Only 16 of the top 50 metro areas gained 25-to-34-year-olds from 1990 to 2000, and they are the best-educated, most mobile part of the U.S. population. (Just to complete the math, that also means 34 metro areas actually lost 25-34 year-olds in that decade.)
There's only one sustainable way to increase talent in most communities, and that is to develop it. It means we're going to have to do the work all along the education spectrum to make it happen.
But the goal is by no means out of reach. We've found that in all 30 of the markets we've studied, if we could simply get 3 to 4 percent of those with some college to complete their degrees, we could achieve the Talent Dividend.
Jim Collins admonishes CEOs to "get the right people on the bus" if they want to build companies that last. Cities must do the same thing. But unlike companies, cities don't have the luxury of hiring and firing their citizens. Instead, they have to work with what they have. And that means turning the city into a talent-producing machine.
Which city will step up to the challenge first? The one that does, wins.
Carol Coletta is the President and CEO of CEOs for Cities, and the host of the nationally-syndicated public radio show, Smart City.
How Helsinki Became a Public Transporation Paradise One European city plans to make car ownership obsolete within a decade
Follow the Crowd NanoCrafter and the rise of group intelligence Why online gaming may just be the future of science
The Empathy Mirror Neurofeedback enables us to better see ourselves in the other. Recent discoveries in neurofeedback can teach you to be less of a dick.
Robots On Ice Probe the Arctic Why a team of research robots is investigating disappearing sea ice, and why you should care.
Don’t Turn Away Colin Finlay photographs the consequences of climate change. You will never see more beautiful photos of the deteriorating state of our planet than the ones in this photo feature.
Puppy Love How dogecoin spawned an improbable community of giving What a canine-emblazoned cryptocurrency can teach about philanthropy
Positive In, Positive Out: How a USC Alumna is Coping with Lymphoma Coast Guard Reserves member Cassie Sulfridge, 28, had just graduated from MSW@USC, the Southern California university’s web-based Master of Social Work program, and was working two jobs when her life was turned upside down.
Politics by Yummier Means An Israeli-Palestinian popup restaurant and the precarious art of gastric diplomacy Two chefs win over hearts, minds, and stomachs in Jerusalem.
Rag Time Seven seriously f’d up t-shirts that somehow made their way onto shelves Brazil’s “lookin’ to score” tee is, unfortunately, part of a recent tradition of aberrant apparel.
LeBron James Complicates Cleveland's Comeback Story Returning to Cleveland, LeBron James contends with a city’s past and conflicting views of its future
The Equalizers For these Brazilian footballing legends, competitive play wasn’t a diversion from societal ills, but a means to redress them. A secret history of the fight for social justice among Brazil’s greatest soccer stars of the past century
The Real Implications of Detroit’s $500 Houses Sometimes the Rent is Too Damn Low