Is Closing Schools Really the Best Solution?
Closing schools has become an almost reflexive, corporate solution to a complex fiscal and social problem—a problem to which no one has found a satisfying answer.
Districts shutter, sell, or destroy physical properties typically for fiscal reasons. Districts also terminate contracts of poor-performing service providers to make way for new leaders who most often radically rearrange the organs of a school—making it in essence a new school. In either case for students, alumni, and family members, closing a school can feel like excommunicating a grandfather to the wilderness to save money.
In Michigan, the Saginaw School District must fill a $32.6 million hole by the 2015-2016 school year. Alumni tears soaked the plan to close their beloved Saginaw High. The subsequent community pressure stopped the vote to close "Sag High," and the district found other cost-cutting measures to keep open two schools that it had planned to close. Political pressure forced this district to open their eyes to other possibilities and solutions.
In post-Katrina New Orleans, taking a school offline is more often about ushering out a poor-performing educational service provider of a charter school due to stunted academic growth. The Recovery School District (RSD) recently closed much-publicized John McDonogh High School. The Oprah Television Network dubiously featured "John Mac" in the mini-series Blackboard Wars in what was hoped to narrate an arc of improvement. Instead, within two years the RSD did not seek a temporary home for John Mac. This effectively discontinued the school and its provider, Future Is Now, amid poor performance, declining enrollments, large deficits, and a media tragedy. Blackboard Wars stopped filming before graduation.
Times Picayune columnist Jarvis DeBerry wrote an emblematic letter that captures one of the reasons why district leaders need better solutions. DeBerry opens his letter with, "It is with heavy hearts that we, the residents of New Orleans, write you this letter informing you that we find it impossible to educate you. We're giving up on our stated goal of preparing you for a future that requires your literacy, your facility with numbers, and critical thinking skills. You have our regrets." This quote reveals the hidden curriculum of school closing.
But grief is not the only tradeoff in need of a solution. Closing schools doesn't always cure multifaceted financial problems. Let's be clear, shuttering is about cutting expenses—i.e., letting go of teachers. Releasing teachers can be a convenient and nefarious way to close a financial gap. Nevertheless, we do need to rethink how the vestiges of segregation, busing, as well as the school-choice agenda led to attendance-zone planning with the efficiency rating of a bowl of spaghetti. We very well may have more campuses than needed, but across-the-board cutting ignores poor planning, bad policy, and mismanagement, which often times remain with the district. In addition, closing a school due to academic failure doesn't guarantee its students will end up in a better school.
Taking schools offline can be incredibly shortsighted for communities that need reinvestment. Schools are cultural assets that drive neighborhood economies. Closing a school can bury history while bankrupting a nearby gas station. Shuttering removes meeting and recreational space especially for vulnerable populations. No one really wins when a school closes prematurely.
Many urban districts will realize population growth. By 2050, most of the world's population will live in urban areas. Improving public school districts are presenting strong cases to parents of faith based and private schools to come back to the public sector. As schools improve and cities grow, district leaders should explicitly seek to add revenue by recruiting private and faith-based families. Tuition has mirrored the rising cost of education, and no one wants to pay twice for education.
Consequently, more and more families are following their tax dollars but are also demanding better public options. Districts in growing metropolitan areas should do everything to keep schools open while improving them. If leaders leave little academic and physical room for growth, then recruitment becomes difficult. School closing is a solution in need of a solution. But what alternatives exist for districts?
Colleges of education should physically and literally be part of the solution. Schools and universities must partner in ways to maximize their economic and social benefits with the explicit goal of sustaining and growing neighborhoods. I always remind people that the goal of school reform is not simply to close an achievement gap. We should find ways to support students and reform schools and maintain community assets.
The newfound space in schools allows for meaningful co-locations and partnerships. Universities can slow their penchant to grow their footprint and raise tuition by utilizing the real life learning laboratory available in their backyards. Schools—not university campuses—provide the best training ground for future teachers. By giving students "on the job" learning experiences, students can determine if teaching is a viable career choice. Likewise, the principal and district also can see the talent they would want to hire.
On the topic of student-teaching time: most states require 12 weeks of service. Candidates should spend much more time establishing relationships with students and staff to effectively transition in the role. Instead of building academic monuments that disconnect students from communities and make smart people poor, colleges of education should make curricula more responsive to the needs of larger community. Course work should be much more experiential. Course work in teacher education should be practiced. Schools have space and time to be shared. Candidates should learn at least a year within a building. Candidates would be considered apprentices who have been groomed for the role.
I never understood why teacher education faculty offices reside away from schools. Faculty can provide immediate feedback to candidates as well as employed teachers. Faculty members become antiquated when removed from professional environments. In addition, how many media resource and lesson planning libraries sit empty within pristine colleges of education, waiting to be utilized? Likewise, schools need the additional human power and resources to give teachers the ability to differentiate instruction, call families, and mitigate disputes. Colleges of education must move into K-12 spaces.
Colleges of education shouldn't be the only entities that reside in a school. Schools in some districts may have gotten smaller, but the needs of students are often greater. Poor mental and physical health, "houselessness" and lack of aftercare hurt teachers and students' earnest efforts. Students, particularly in urban districts, need additional support for success: wrap-around services, health care, and mentoring are all things schools could use effectively to fill space.
Many service providers would welcome working inside a school. The transactional costs that support providers incur because the distance between them and their clients hinder providers' capacity to offer services. Support providers must go to the need—the schools themselves. However, district leaders need partnership agreements that make fiscal and programmatic sense. Too many missions in a building create chaos.
Clearly, these solutions cannot completely solve the budgetary dilemmas of Philadelphia or Detroit, but colleges of education should see a bigger opportunity to build capacity of districts, schools, and candidates.
Andre Perry, founding dean of urban education at Davenport University in Grand Rapids, Mich., is the author of The Garden Path: The Miseducation of a City.
A version of this post appeared at the Hechinger Report
Image via Shutterstock
The Message-Maker: On the Ground with Baltimore Street Artist GAIA Internationally acclaimed artist uses painting to reach his city.
Buckets are the New Pumpkins Do you annually waste nourishing squash flesh on bourgeois porch displays? Jettison the traditional jack-o’-lantern with this one simple trick
Watch Out for the Witch Flick A guide to the positive, negative, and complicated depictions of women as witches in movies, warts and all
The Not-So-Mad Science of Head Transplants We may soon be able to successfully graft a human head onto a different body, but is it worth the cost in terms of dollars and ethics?
A Friendly Game of International Border Subversion Activists in Morocco and Algeria hope to play a volleyball game using the countries’ mutual border as a net
13 Spooky Sites That Redefine the Term Skeleton Structure Humans have been using bones as building materials for centuries While world religions and ancient history are replete with alternative burial solutions, some of the most mesmerizing are found in ossuaries
Teacher’s Little Reading Helper Know any child iPad addicts who should be learning how to read instead of playing Candy Crush? Try Bam Boomerang
How Elves and Serpents are Saving Iceland for Future Generations Most Iceland residents believe in magic to some degree, and it’s helping to preserve the environment, foster community … and rake in tourism dollars
5 Tales of Halloween Heartbreak A conversation about growing up in the U.S. without celebrating national dress-up-and-get-free-candy day
Thomas Nestor Jr. Joins the Ranks Read more ›