New Code: Giving Back in Business from the Ground Up
People in the advertising industry like to talk about this thing called "cause marketing." Essentially, it’s when a for-profit business teams up with a non-profit organization or cause for a mutual benefit. At the risk of sounding overly cynical, the business gets to tell the story of its altruism while the charity gets a healthy infusion of cash.
You may not have been aware that there’s a term for this, but you’ve definitely seen it in your everyday life: Gap’s (Red) Campaign, General Mills Box Tops, and others. This model is not really new; the first well-known case was probably Marriott and the March of Dimes, a collaboration that dates back to the 1970s.
While it’s hard to argue the positive effects that cause marketing can have on both a charity and a brand (at least in the short term), the entire model came under scrutiny recently, when Warren Buffett’s son, Peter Buffett, wrote an op-ed for the New York Times entitled the “The Charitable-Industrial Complex.”
In it, Buffett calls for a new concept of philanthropy. He decries corporate leaders and investment managers with traditional notions of giving back—that is, cutting checks toward noble causes to feel better about working within a system that “creates vast amounts of wealth for the few.”
He explains how this model for charity is also spreading to companies and brands, who’ve come to expect a return on investment (ROI) for philanthropic acts. As an advertising copywriter, I know those businesses and brands pretty well. I’ve crafted their stories, written their mission statements, spun their campaigns to connect with audiences on an emotional level. And while I was doing so, I went back and forth on the effectiveness of this model. On the one hand, money is money—does it matter the company’s motive for doing something good? On the other hand, it never seemed like a sustainable way to solve any major social problems, like poverty, and AIDS, the sex trade, and education. As Buffett so eloquently put it, “it can only kick the can down the road.”
But last month, I was given the opportunity to write a different story. I want to talk about it here because it seems to be a rising trend, and I think it has more promise for our future.
Its not a trickle down story of philanthropy, in which big corporations spread seeds of wealth to different causes, but a trickle up story, in which companies create positive change by design, by their very nature, and from the ground up. It’s the story of an online marketplace called Given Goods, which carries products from more than 70 different “storydoing” brands. These brands were founded on a mission to do good—for the environment, for global development, for human rights, and for business. Giving back is not an investment for them; it’s in their DNA.
My assignment has been to write the profiles and backstories of each of these 70 brands, and in doing so I’ve discovered a whole new kind of commerce. It’s not just TOMS anymore. There’s a glassware company in Boise, Idaho, called Usful, which transforms discarded glass bottles into home goods, while putting homeless and financially struggling people to work. There’s a fashion label called Far & Wide Collective, which sells clothing and accessories made by global artisans, empowering women to sustain their own businesses. There’s a sound systems company called Vers that has a net positive impact on the environment—all their products are made of wood, but for each tree used in production, they plant 100 more. And there’s a backpack company called Ark, which makes its products in the U.S. and donates a backpack to a student in need for every backpack sold.
That’s only a few of the stories I’ve discovered; there are many more, and they’re all inspiring. At some point I realized that these companies differ from the ones Peter Buffett described in one important way: they walk the walk. “Doing good” and “giving back” extends to every aspect of their business—from sourcing materials, to production, to wages, and beyond. They don’t need a marketing campaign to show they give back, because their business model is designed to uplift everyone it touches. Consumers can feel that; all these brands need to do is tell their (true) stories, and hopefully, shoppers will come.
Buffett wrapped up his article with an intriguing call to arms: “It’s time for a new operating system,” he says. “Not a 2.0 or a 3.0, but something built from the ground up. New code.”
I can only hope he is reading this, because there’s an entire movement of people out there that has already started building. All we need now is for consumers to realize the power in their wallets, and make “good” choices when it’s time to decide where to shop.
Philanthropy image via Shutterstock
This Yoga-in-Schools Program Just Raised $31,000 in Crowdfunding R.I.S.E. introduces Bay Area teens to yoga, to help with self-image, grades, and other adolescent nightmares.
A New Olympics Just For Nomads Playing polo with a 100-pound goat carcass to save nomadic culture and build national pride in Kyrgyzstan.
New Detroit Program Trades Houses for Literary Excellence Write a House names Brooklyn poet Casey Rocheteau as first recipient of free home in Detroit
A Chance in Hell Yaks, America, and The Apocalypse Up against an $88 billion beef industry, it takes a leap of faith to raise yak in the United States.
Specialty Coffee Retailers Try to Prove They're Good to the Last Drop Searching for the perfect cup of sustainable and ethically produced joe. #NationalCoffeeDay
Metalhead Ballerinas Rock the U.K. Brutal Ballet slayed U.K. audiences last week with the debut of original choreography set to a metal cover of the Game of Thrones themesong.
You’re Now a Two-Minute Video Away from Getting into College
Goucher College will accept video applications in lieu of the traditional essays and test scores.
3 Epic Racial Profiling Blunders from History
Racial profiling not only harms innocent people of color, it can cause law enforcement to lose crucial time in pursuing the true criminals.
10 Overlooked Issues That People are Protesting This Week at the U.N.
The U.N. General Assembly is a magnet for protest from every race, color, and creed. Meet some of the people behind the picketing.
Why We Still Need the Nation State Overshadowed by international organizations, global commerce, and even individual cities, the nation state still has a vital role to play.
Flip-Flopping on Fats Health and sustainability concerns drive the two largest donut chains to change their policies on palm oil.
The Challenge of Branding a Life-Threatening Disease Can mitochondrial disease go mainstream? There are promising developments for mitochondrial disease in genetics and cellular therapies—now, if only it could get some buzz.